kwin/tests/test_client_machine.cpp

158 lines
5.1 KiB
C++
Raw Normal View History

Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
/********************************************************************
KWin - the KDE window manager
This file is part of the KDE project.
Copyright (C) 2013 Martin Gräßlin <mgraesslin@kde.org>
This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or
(at your option) any later version.
This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the
GNU General Public License for more details.
You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
along with this program. If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
*********************************************************************/
#include "testutils.h"
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
// KWin
#include "../atoms.h" // needed for utils to compile
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
#include "../client_machine.h"
#include "../utils.h"
#include "../xcbutils.h"
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
// Qt
#include <QApplication>
#include <QtTest/QtTest>
// xcb
#include <xcb/xcb.h>
// system
#include <unistd.h>
#include <sys/types.h>
#include <sys/socket.h>
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
#include <netdb.h>
namespace KWin {
// just to make the linker of utils happy
Atoms* atoms;
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
}
using namespace KWin;
class TestClientMachine : public QObject
{
Q_OBJECT
private slots:
void initTestCase();
void cleanupTestCase();
void hostName_data();
void hostName();
void emptyHostName();
private:
void setClientMachineProperty(xcb_window_t window, const QByteArray &hostname);
QByteArray m_hostName;
QByteArray m_fqdn;
};
void TestClientMachine::setClientMachineProperty(xcb_window_t window, const QByteArray &hostname)
{
xcb_change_property(connection(), XCB_PROP_MODE_REPLACE, window,
XCB_ATOM_WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, XCB_ATOM_STRING, 8,
hostname.length(), hostname.constData());
}
void TestClientMachine::initTestCase()
{
#ifdef HOST_NAME_MAX
char hostnamebuf[HOST_NAME_MAX];
#else
char hostnamebuf[256];
#endif
if (gethostname(hostnamebuf, sizeof hostnamebuf) >= 0) {
hostnamebuf[sizeof(hostnamebuf)-1] = 0;
m_hostName = hostnamebuf;
}
addrinfo *res;
addrinfo addressHints;
memset(&addressHints, 0, sizeof(addressHints));
addressHints.ai_family = PF_UNSPEC;
addressHints.ai_socktype = SOCK_STREAM;
addressHints.ai_flags |= AI_CANONNAME;
if (getaddrinfo(m_hostName.constData(), NULL, &addressHints, &res) == 0) {
if (res->ai_canonname) {
m_fqdn = QByteArray(res->ai_canonname);
}
}
freeaddrinfo(res);
}
void TestClientMachine::cleanupTestCase()
{
}
void TestClientMachine::hostName_data()
{
QTest::addColumn<QByteArray>("hostName");
QTest::addColumn<QByteArray>("expectedHost");
QTest::addColumn<bool>("local");
QTest::newRow("empty") << QByteArray() << QByteArray("localhost") << true;
QTest::newRow("localhost") << QByteArray("localhost") << QByteArray("localhost") << true;
QTest::newRow("hostname") << m_hostName << m_hostName << true;
QTest::newRow("HOSTNAME") << m_hostName.toUpper() << m_hostName.toUpper() << true;
QByteArray cutted(m_hostName);
cutted.remove(0, 1);
QTest::newRow("ostname") << cutted << cutted << false;
QByteArray domain("random.name.not.exist.tld");
QTest::newRow("domain") << domain << domain << false;
QTest::newRow("fqdn") << m_fqdn << m_fqdn << true;
QTest::newRow("FQDN") << m_fqdn.toUpper() << m_fqdn.toUpper() << true;
cutted = m_fqdn;
cutted.remove(0, 1);
QTest::newRow("qdn") << cutted << cutted << false;
}
void TestClientMachine::hostName()
{
const QRect geometry(0, 0, 10, 10);
const uint32_t values[] = { true };
Xcb::Window window(geometry, XCB_WINDOW_CLASS_INPUT_ONLY, XCB_CW_OVERRIDE_REDIRECT, values);
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
QFETCH(QByteArray, hostName);
QFETCH(bool, local);
setClientMachineProperty(window, hostName);
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
ClientMachine clientMachine;
QSignalSpy spy(&clientMachine, SIGNAL(localhostChanged()));
clientMachine.resolve(window, XCB_WINDOW_NONE);
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
QTEST(clientMachine.hostName(), "expectedHost");
int i=0;
while (clientMachine.isResolving() && i++ < 50) {
// name is being resolved in an external thread, so let's wait a little bit
QTest::qWait(250);
}
QCOMPARE(clientMachine.isLocal(), local);
QCOMPARE(spy.isEmpty(), !local);
}
void TestClientMachine::emptyHostName()
{
const QRect geometry(0, 0, 10, 10);
const uint32_t values[] = { true };
Xcb::Window window(geometry, XCB_WINDOW_CLASS_INPUT_ONLY, XCB_CW_OVERRIDE_REDIRECT, values);
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
ClientMachine clientMachine;
QSignalSpy spy(&clientMachine, SIGNAL(localhostChanged()));
clientMachine.resolve(window, XCB_WINDOW_NONE);
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
QCOMPARE(clientMachine.hostName(), ClientMachine::localhost());
QVERIFY(clientMachine.isLocal());
// should be local
QCOMPARE(spy.isEmpty(), false);
}
KWIN_TEST_MAIN(TestClientMachine)
Improved resolving whether a window is on local machine Most windows use the hostname in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE, but there are windows using the FQDN (for example libreoffice). So instead of "foo" it is "foo.local.net" or similar. The logic so far has been unable to properly determine whether windows with FQDN are on the local system. In order to solve this problem the handling is split out into an own class which stores the information of hostname and whether it is a local machine. This is to not query multiple times. To determine whether the Client is on the local system getaddrinfo is used for the own hostname and the FQDN provided in WM_CLIENT_MACHINE. If one of the queried names matches, we know that it is on the local machine. The old logic to compare the hostname is still used and getaddrinfo is only a fallback in case hostname does not match. The problem with getaddrinfo is, that it accesses the network and by that could block. To circumvent this problem the calls are moved into threads by using QtConcurrent::run. Obviously this brings disadvantages. When trying to resolve whether a Client is on the local machine and a FQDN is used, the information is initially wrong. The new ClientMachine class emits a signal when the information that the system is local becomes available, but for some things this is just too late: * window rules are already gathered * Session Management has already taken place In both cases this is an acceptable loss. For window rules it just needs a proper matching of the machine in case of localhost (remote hosts are not affected). And the case of session management is very academic as it is unlikely that a restoring session contains remote windows. BUG: 308391 FIXED-IN: 4.11 REVIEW: 108235
2013-01-07 07:07:27 +00:00
#include "test_client_machine.moc"